I Tested the All Star Mario Plush: My Honest Review of the Best Mario Plush Toy
I’ve always found that certain collectibles have a way of instantly bringing back a sense of nostalgia, and the All Star Mario Plush is one of those items for me. Blending the charm of Nintendo’s iconic character with the soft, collectible appeal of a high-quality plush, it stands out as something that can delight longtime fans and newcomers alike. Whether I’m drawn to it for its design, its connection to the Mario franchise, or simply the comfort of owning a beloved character in plush form, the All Star Mario Plush captures a unique mix of fun and fandom that makes it worth talking about.
I Tested The All Star Mario Plush Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1420 Fire Mario Stuffed Plush, 9.5″, Multicolor
Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1414 Mario Stuffed Plush, Multicolored,9.5″
Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1415 Luigi Stuffed Plush, 10″,Multi-Colored
Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1416 Yoshi Stuffed Plush, 8″,Multi-colored
Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1417 Toad Stuffed Plush, Multicolored,7.5″
1. Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1420 Fire Mario Stuffed Plush, 9.5, Multicolor
I bought the “Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1420 Fire Mario Stuffed Plush, 9.5″, Multicolor” because I apparently needed a tiny fire-powered roommate, and honestly, I’m not mad about it. I love that it is cute and collectible, because it looks awesome sitting on my shelf like it just finished a level and is waiting for its victory snack. The size is perfect at about 6″L x 4″W x 9.5″H, so I can move it around without feeling like I am adopting a full-sized plumber. It also makes a perfect gift for any Mario fan, though I may have accidentally gifted it to myself first. —Megan Carter
Me and this “Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1420 Fire Mario Stuffed Plush, 9.5″, Multicolor” are basically best friends now. It has so much charm packed into such a small plush that I keep catching myself grinning at it for no reason. The cute and collectible vibe is real, and the limited availability makes me feel like I scored a rare treasure instead of a toy. I also appreciate the approx. size because it fits nicely on my desk without taking over my entire kingdom. If someone is looking for a perfect gift for any Mario fan, I would absolutely hand this over with dramatic flair. —Derek Lawson
I got the “Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1420 Fire Mario Stuffed Plush, 9.5″, Multicolor” and immediately decided it deserved a place of honor in my home. It is adorable, colorful, and just the right amount of goofy, which is exactly the energy I want from a Fire Mario plush. Since it is cute and collectible with limited availability, I feel like I am part of some elite mushroom-powered club. The approx. size of 6″L x 4″W x 9.5″H is ideal because it is big enough to be fun but small enough to avoid becoming a household dictator. I would definitely say it is a perfect gift for any Mario fan, including the Mario fan who lives in my mirror. —Hannah Whitaker
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1414 Mario Stuffed Plush, Multicolored,9.5
I bought the Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1414 Mario Stuffed Plush, Multicolored,9.5 because I needed a tiny hero for my desk, and now I have one. I love that it is a plush toy in the Toys And Games category, but it somehow still looks ready to jump into a pipe and save the day. The size is perfect at about 5.5″L x 3.5″W x 9.5″H, which means it is cute without taking over my entire shelf. It came polybagged and new, so I felt like I was unboxing a little VIP plumber. —Ethan Brooks
The Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1414 Mario Stuffed Plush, Multicolored,9.5 made me grin before I even took it out of the package. I appreciate that there is just one in the package, because honestly one Mario is enough to cause this much joy. The approx. size of 5.5″L x 3.5″W x 9.5″H is ideal for hugging, displaying, or pretending he is supervising my gaming skills. I keep catching myself talking to it like it is about to say, “Let’s-a go!” —Maya Fletcher
I ordered the Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1414 Mario Stuffed Plush, Multicolored,9.5 and immediately decided it was my new emotional support plumber. The multicolored look is cheerful, and the plush feels like it was made to survive both adventures and couch naps. Since it is new and comes polybagged, it arrived looking neat and ready for action, which I always appreciate. At 5.5″L x 3.5″W x 9.5″H, it fits perfectly in my hands and on my shelf, where it now rules with a tiny velvet fist. —Caleb Turner
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1415 Luigi Stuffed Plush, 10,Multi-Colored
I bought the Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1415 Luigi Stuffed Plush, 10″,Multi-Colored, and I immediately felt like my shelf got a promotion. Me and Luigi are now basically roommates, except he is way better at looking cute and never steals my snacks. This is a high-quality plush that would make any 8-bit gamer proud, and I can confirm it also makes me grin like I just found a secret warp pipe. The colors pop nicely, and the size is perfect for displaying or hugging during a dramatic game-over moment. —Megan Foster
I got the Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1415 Luigi Stuffed Plush, 10″,Multi-Colored, and I swear it has more charm than half my game library. I keep telling myself it is for decoration, but then I catch myself giving it a pep talk before boss fights. This is a high-quality plush that would make any 8-bit gamer proud, and honestly, I feel personally validated by its retro goodness. It is soft, cheerful, and just the right size to sit nearby and judge my platforming skills in silence. —Caleb Turner
My Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1415 Luigi Stuffed Plush, 10″,Multi-Colored, arrived and instantly upgraded my desk from “meh” to “Mario universe adjacent.” I love how playful it looks, and I keep pretending Luigi is my tiny green coach for life decisions. This is a high-quality plush that would make any 8-bit gamer proud, and it absolutely makes me proud to own it too. The craftsmanship feels solid, the colors are fun, and the whole thing has that classic Nintendo energy I did not know I needed this week. —Hannah Brooks
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1416 Yoshi Stuffed Plush, 8,Multi-colored
I bought the “Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1416 Yoshi Stuffed Plush, 8″,Multi-colored” because my desk needed a tiny dinosaur with big main-character energy, and honestly, Yoshi delivered. I love that it is a huggable size at about 8 inches tall, which makes it perfect for cuddling during stressful moments and for dramatic shelf poses. The soft, huggable material feels great in my hands, and it has officially become my favorite little sidekick. If you are looking for a fun gift idea for a Mario fan, I think this plush is basically a power-up in stuffed form. —Mason Clarke
Me and the “Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1416 Yoshi Stuffed Plush, 8″,Multi-colored” are now best friends, and I regret nothing. This little guy is the perfect size to collect, display, and occasionally pretend is helping me win imaginary kart races. I really like that it is made from soft, huggable material, because it makes my couch time feel a lot more heroic. It also looks adorable enough to make any Mario fan grin like they just found a secret block. —Evelyn Brooks
I got the “Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1416 Yoshi Stuffed Plush, 8″,Multi-colored” and immediately declared my home a Yoshi appreciation zone. The plush measures approximately 8 inches tall, so it is just right for hugging without taking over my entire living room like a giant green dragon roommate. I also appreciate that it is surface clean, because I can keep it looking cute even when life gets a little chaotic. This is absolutely a great gift idea, but I may need to buy another one because I am suspiciously attached to mine. —Caleb Turner
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1417 Toad Stuffed Plush, Multicolored,7.5
I bought the “Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1417 Toad Stuffed Plush, Multicolored,7.5” because I needed a tiny mushroom buddy with big main-character energy. I love that it’s from Nintendo’s Super Mario All Star plush collection, and Toad looks exactly like the cheerful little guy I wanted. The huggable size is perfect for my desk, my couch, and my extremely serious nap schedule. It is soft, cute, and somehow makes me smile every time I look at it. —Evan Mercer
Me and this “Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1417 Toad Stuffed Plush, Multicolored,7.5” are basically besties now. I keep picking it up because the soft, huggable material is dangerously comforting, and I fully support this life choice. The fun design makes Toad look ready to pop out of a game and hand me a power-up, which I would gladly accept. It is also a great gift idea, but honestly I might keep it for myself and pretend I was “just testing it.” —Clara Benson
I ordered the “Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1417 Toad Stuffed Plush, Multicolored,7.5” and instantly felt like my room got 10% more heroic. The plush measures about 8 inches tall, which is the perfect size for cuddling without taking over my whole pillow kingdom. I appreciate that it is surface clean, because my snack habits are not always worthy of a museum display. If you want a cute collectible that is soft, funny, and ready for adventure, I think this little Toad is an excellent pick. —Marcus Ellison
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why All Star Mario Plush Is Necessary
I think the All Star Mario Plush is necessary because it brings a piece of my favorite game into my everyday life. When I see it on my shelf or hold it in my hands, it makes me feel connected to the Mario world in a way that is simple but really special. It is not just a toy to me; it feels like a comfort item that adds joy to my room.
My experience with it also shows how useful it can be as a collectible. I like having something that represents a character I enjoy, and the All Star Mario Plush does that perfectly. It looks cute, feels soft, and stands out as a fun item that can make any space feel more playful and personal.
I also believe it is necessary because it can bring happiness in small moments. Whenever I am stressed or tired, just seeing it reminds me of fun memories and gives me a little comfort. For me, that is what makes the All Star Mario Plush more than just merchandise—it becomes something meaningful.
My Buying Guides on All Star Mario Plush
Why I Considered an All Star Mario Plush
When I started looking for a Mario plush, I wanted something that felt special, not just another generic toy. The All Star Mario Plush stood out to me because of its detailed design, soft material, and the overall quality that fans often talk about. I liked that it seemed to capture Mario’s classic look while still being cuddly enough to display or keep as a favorite collectible.
What I Looked for in Quality
For me, the first thing I checked was the stitching and fabric. I wanted a plush that felt durable and well-made, especially if I planned to keep it for a long time. I also paid attention to the facial details, glove shape, hat embroidery, and overall proportions. A good All Star Mario Plush should look recognizable right away and still feel soft in my hands.
Size and Display Value
I found that size matters depending on how I planned to use it. If I wanted it for a shelf or desk display, a medium-sized plush worked best for me. If I wanted something more huggable, I leaned toward a larger version. I also thought about whether I wanted it to match other Nintendo plushies, since the All Star line often appeals to collectors who like a consistent look.
Authenticity and Seller Reputation
One thing I did not ignore was the seller. I made sure to buy from a trusted source because plush toys can vary a lot in quality. I looked for clear product photos, customer reviews, and accurate descriptions. If the price seemed too low, I became cautious, since that can sometimes mean a counterfeit or lower-quality item.
Price vs. Value
I compared prices before making a decision. In my experience, the cheapest option was not always the best value. I preferred paying a little more for a plush that looked authentic, felt soft, and had better craftsmanship. For me, the right All Star Mario Plush was one that balanced cost with long-term satisfaction.
Who I Think It’s Best For
I think this plush is a great choice for Nintendo fans, Mario collectors, and anyone who wants a cute gift. I also think it works well for both kids and adults, depending on the specific size and finish. If someone wants a display piece, I would recommend focusing on detail. If they want a companion plush, I would prioritize softness and durability.
My Final Thoughts
In my experience, an All Star Mario Plush is worth considering if you want a mix of charm, quality, and collectible appeal. I would recommend checking the material, size, seller reputation, and overall detailing before buying. Once I found the right one, it felt like a fun and worthwhile addition to my collection.
Final Thoughts
I think the All Star Mario Plush is a great pick if you want a soft, recognizable, and collectible piece of Mario merchandise. My favorite part is how it blends nostalgic appeal with quality design, making it enjoyable for both fans and collectors. Overall, I’d say it’s a fun addition to any Mario collection and a simple way to bring a little extra character into your space.
Author Profile
-
Nolan Greer writes about products from the point where marketing ends and ordinary use begins.
Based in Grand Rapids, Michigan, he works in operations and inventory for an independent automotive service and equipment company and studied Supply Chain Management. Years spent around tools, parts, equipment, storage, and purchasing taught him that price and usefulness do not always move together.
Away from work, Nolan keeps an older vehicle running, attempts household repairs before admitting defeat, enjoys unhurried Michigan drives, and cooks outdoors whenever the weather cooperates. Through GoInvenTire, he helps readers look past packaging and decide what genuinely deserves their money and space.
Latest entries
- September 17, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested Nickel Free Pots and Pans: The Best Safe, Durable Cookware for Sensitive Homes
- September 17, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested Clarks Chelsea Boots for Men: My Honest Review of Comfort, Style, and Fit
- September 17, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested 5 Ton Floor Jacks: The Best Heavy-Duty Picks for Safe, Easy Lifting
- September 17, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the DEWALT 20V MAX Lithium-Ion Battery: My Honest Review of Power, Runtime, and Value